general relativity for babies What Is The Universe Expanding Into?

I get this question... a lot.

"Since astronomers know that the Universe is expanding, what's it expanding into? What's outside of the Universe?"

The short answer is that this is a nonsense question, the Universe isn't expanding into anything, it's just expanding.

The definition of the Universe is that it contains everything.

If something was outside the Universe, it would also be part of the Universe too.

Outside of that? Still Universe. Out side of THAT? Also more Universe. It's Universe all the way down.

But I know you're going to find that answer unsatisfying, so now I'm going to break your brain.

Either the Universe is infinite, going on forever, or its finite, with a limited volume.

In either case, the Universe has no edge.

When we imagine the Universe expanding after the Big Bang, we imagine an explosion, with a spray of matter coming from a single point. But this analogy isn't accurate.

A better analogy is the surface of an expanding balloon. Not the 3 dimensional balloon, just its 2 dimensional surface.

If you were an ant crawling around the surface of a huge balloon, and the balloon was your whole universe, you would see the balloon as essentially flat under your feet.

Imagine the balloon is inflating. In every direction you look, other ants are moving away from you. The further they are, the faster away they're moving.

Even though it feels like a flat surface, walk in any direction long enough and you'd return to your starting point.

You might imagine a growing circle and wonder what it's expanding into. But that's a nonsense question. There's no direction you could crawl that would get you outside the surface. Your 2-dimensional ant brain can't comprehend an expanding 3-dimensional object.

There may be a centre to the balloon, but there's no center to the surface. Just a shape that extends in all directions and wraps in upon itself.

And yet, your journey to make one lap around the balloon takes longer and longer as the balloon gets more inflated.

To better understand how this relates to our Universe, we need to scale things up by one dimension, from a 2-d surface embedded in a 3-d world, to a 3-d volume embedded within a 4-d universe.

Astronomers think that if you travel in any direction far enough, you'll return to your starting position. If you could stare far enough into space, you would be looking at the back of your own head.

And so, as the Universe expands, it would take you longer and longer to lap the Universe and return to your starting position.

But there's no direction you could travel in that would take you outside or "off" of the Universe.

Even if you could move faster than the speed of light, you'd just return to your starting position more quickly.

We see other galaxies moving away from us in all directions just as our ant would see other ants moving away on the surface of the balloon.

A great analogy comes from my Astronomy Cast co-host, Dr. Pamela Gay.

Instead of an explosion, imagine the expanding Universe is like a loaf of raisin bread rising in the oven.

From the perspective of any raisin, all the other raisins are moving away in all directions.

But unlike a loaf of raisin bread, you could travel in any one direction within the bread and eventually return to your starting raisin.

Remember that our entire comprehension is based on 3-dimensions. If we were 4-dimensional creatures, this would make much more sense.

For a much deeper explanation, I highly recommend you watch my good friend, Zogg the Alien explain how the Universe has no edge.

After watching his videos, you should totally understand the possible topologies of our Universe.

I hope this helps you understand why there's no answer to "what is the Universe expanding into?"

With no edge, it's not expanding into anything, it's just expanding.

general relativity for babies What Is The Universe Expanding Into?
790 Likes	790 Dislikes
74,102 views views	253K followers
Science & Technology	Upload TimePublished on 27 Nov 2013

Related keywords

3-drive compact,3-drive · blp,galaxy a10,space news in tamil,space news nasa,3-drive · remote,expansion joint filler,fraser cain age,expanding brain meme template,space time explained,2-dpmp,expanding universe of ashley garcia,astronomy domine letra,astronomy news,3-デオキシグルコソン,4-daagse feesten,relativity community,fraser cain credentials,science magazine,4-daagse app,physics formula sheet,stephen hawking movie,astronomy tools,big bang theory netflix,relativity equations,physics jobs,einstein quotes,expanding universe model,galaxies mtl squonk rdta,universe today podcast,einstein rosen bridge,general relativity for mathematicians,universe 25,stars simply red,universe today newsletter,universe today,space jam 2 cast,universe today venus,cosmos cafe,3-d集計,expansion bolt,stephen hawking books,mars attacks,fraser cain wiki,big bang top,physics for dummies,marsha p johnson,astronomy letra,universe quotes,space news moon,c-space king edward,fraser cain wikipedia,stephen hawking wife,space time definition,big bang theory season 1,expanding universe worksheet,physics formulas,2-deoxy-d-ribose,if the universe is expanding what's it expanding into,universe today pluto,galaxies spirales,nasa shirt,gravity tales,space time compression definition,cosmos a spacetime odyssey,expanding foam,3-drive・pro,galaxy a30,stars royale,cosmology books,stephen hawking death,nasal decongestant,galaxy s7,galaxy para siempre,space time continuum theory,galaxy s8,galaxy s9,nasal cavity,universe meaning,stars born in 1969,cosmos meaning,earth science regents,3-dセキュア,big bang theory lyrics,4-delige sparco wieldoppenset lazio 14-inch zwart/grijs,universe of obligation,fraser cain bio,galaxy a20,cosmos menu,cosmos drink,expansion diffusion,fraser cains actor,cosmos granite,starscream,3-d the catalogue,fraser cain book,galaxies invisibles,universe tickets,marshmello,universe today jupiter,speed of metric expansion of space,science museum london,c-space-solutions,metric expansion of space and spacetime,c-space community,earthlink webmail,universe expansion effect,2-dimethylaminoethanol,galaxy a50,nasa florida,relativity software,expansion valve ac,stephen hawking children,universe expansion slowing,general relativity for dummies,science fiction lyrics,nasa lyrics,4-daagse feesten nijmegen 2019,science daily,cosmology weinberg pdf,expanding universe balloon,dark energy screens,stephen hawking contribution,galaxy note 10,universe today fraser cain,dark energy battery,space news mars,general relativity an introduction for physicists,space mountain,expansion card,universe expansion rate,universe today book,astronomy metallica,4-delige schuifpui,expanding universe,4-daagse marbella,universe definition,einstein theory of relativity,science fiction,astronomy picture of the day,physics memes,cosmology philosophy,c-space market,galaxy a70,infinite campus fuhsd,fraser cain wife,cosmos db,universe today news,nasal congestion,universe today mars,space time continuum meme,starsector,4-d model,universe today neptune,universe expansion coefficient,4-daagse,expanding universe video,nasa news,fraser cain podcast,space jam,physics equations,galaxies visibles à l'oeil nu,cosmology on the beach 2019,stephen hawking black hole,cosmology degree,physics calculator,universe age,is the universe expanding into empty space,stars hollow,infinite geometric series,universe today years of the planets,cosmos club,galaxies mtl rta,marshall plan,expanding universe peace obelisk,universe expansion in quran,physics jokes,science advances,expanding our philosophical frames,general relativity paper,c-space manufacturing,what is the universe expanding into quizlet,universe expansion dark energy,stephen hawking invention,science direct elsevier,astronomy domine lyrics,expanding envelope plastic,c-space calgary,3-drive初期設定,astronomy domine tab,relativity ediscovery,space news india,relativity galilean,gravity chords,physics definition,c-space chichester college,cosmos season 2,starstruck,science bits,universe today mercury,physics games,gravity force,expansion definition,marshall store,physics terms,gravity meaning,cosmology news,space news articles,3-drive · α,general relativity books,expansion plug,space time fabric,c-space architects ltd,einstein invention,4-delige messenset van berlinger haus (zwart & roségoud),galaxies univers,galaxy j6,universe expansion and time,dark energy definition,earthquake now,c-space india.com,universe expansion velocity,galaxy j4,nasa hoodie,space news in hindi,universe expansion balloon analogy,2d art,4-daagse van nijmegen,expanding binomials,space jam 2,expansion joint,general relativity pdf,expansionism,4-daagse alkmaar,4-d optiek arnhem,big bang finale,universe sandbox,astronomy reddit,dark energy pre workout,general relativity conference 2019,gravity john mayer,3-drive・evo,relativity of simultaneity,cosmology of kyoto,3-drive · ac,c-space vim,astronomy software,stephen hawking contribution to science,sciencealert,nasa jobs,einsteinian universe,universe tattoo,expansion synonym,infinite campus husd,galaxies elliptiques,expanding theory,fraser cain patreon,fraser cain biography,expanding universe productions,universe of stories,expanding folder long,earthquake near me,2d barcode,relativity definition,fraser cain youtube,2-day shipping,c-space china,relativity space,science direct,galaxy j4 core,stars vs las fuerzas del mal,space newsletter,relativity general,expanding universe theory,starshelper,expanding brain meme,gravity value,general relativity for mathematicians pdf,nasa space center,relativity theory definition,einstein wife,sciences po,4-daagse nijmegen 2020,3-d matrix,expansion diffusion definition,gravity falls characters,spacex stock,physics gre,space news websites,2d design,c-space backpack,cosmology meaning,galaxy edge,astronomy for dummies pdf,dark energy equation,general relativity definition,marshall beach,general relativity equation,big bang kpop,nasacort,expanding synonym,relativity theory,dark energy vs dark matter,relativity معنى,einstein and eddington,science hub,galaxy s10 precio,stephen hawking theories,universe today saturn,expanding earth hypothesis,gravity unit,big bang bernadette,universe expansion acceleration rate,science kombat,galaxies hubble,nasa astronaut anne mcclain,2-diethylaminoethanol,universe today twitter,space needle,space news podcast,big bang theory season 12,expanding calculator,big bang pizza,infinite jest,expanding horizons,universe expansion faster than light,4-daagse apeldoorn,2-deoxyglucose,general relativity wald,relativity book,big bang theory ending,c-space project mars,starship,astronomy domine chords,fraser cain newsletter,galaxy s10,fraser cain twitter,universe today uranus,general relativity for babies pdf,infinite campus sjusd,2-drawer file cabinet,astronomy lyrics,space time coordinates,universe background,physics classroom,physics regents,4-daagse 2020,earthquake california,astronomy and astrophysics,dark energy creations,nasal vestibulitis,marshmallow,cosmos possible worlds,universe today logo,cosmology definition,stephen hawking quotes,space center houston,expansion joint material,c-space careers,cosmology inflation,eartha kitt,expanding brain,space time relativity,2-d gorillaz,cosmos pizza denver,cosmos laundromat,dark energy charger,infinite kpop,universe today app,cosmosphere,einstein iq,cosmology without god,fraser cain net worth,stephen hawking last words,universe expansion theory,big bang theory theme song,cosmology steven weinberg pdf,4-daagse nieuws,space news daily,space time continuum,general relativity and gravitation,expanding file folder,marshall ca,timeline of the metric expansion of space,astronomy names,earth signs,starset,starship troopers,relativity theory special,universe expansion equation,big bang theory wiki,gravity definition,stephen hawking big bang,infinite campus monta vista,universe today patreon,dark energy facts,galaxy a7,galaxy buds,expanding envelope,stephen hawking discoveries,nasal polyps,nasa fcu,universe sandbox free,space time and matter,2d shapes,universe today big bang theory,cosmos travel,2-digit country codes,expansion capital group,space news app,space time singularity,earth lyrics,galaxies connues,starships letra,space timeline,infinite mirror maze,earth lil dicky,marshalls san jose,expanding universe proof,starship troopers 3,physics girl,starship troopers 2,expanding folder,galaxy s10e,relativity the special and the general theory,fraser cain education,general relativity theory,gravity constant,infinite thai,fraser cain email,cosmos flower,earth wind and fire,stephen hawking voice,space time pbs,c-space 37-45 city road,dark energy survey,stephen hawking age,relativity of time,infinite lists,infinite campus srvusd,space crime,expanding universe lab,marshawn lynch,spacex,big bang theory episodes,universe synonym,space time compression,earth shoes,space news now,c-space robotics,earth fare,infinite campus,marsai martin,einsteinium,earthquake bay area,earthquake today,science research,expanding universe animation,expanding universe hubble,universe expansion faster than speed of light,dark energy spectroscopic instrument,relativity media,4-delige bk flow pannenset,stars wars 9,stars wars 8,nasa houston,2-d herbicide label,space news 2019,gravity movie,gravity lyrics john mayer,gravity lyrics sara,gravity lyrics,2-drawer lateral file cabinet,3-drive · pro,big bang theory characters,expansion tank,space coast credit union,gravity sara bareilles,science en español,stephen hawking story,theories of what the universe is expanding into,einstein riddle,infinitesimal,what is the universe expanding into youtube,earthgang,astronomy metallica lyrics,space cowboys,space news asteroid,earthlink,nasal spray,gravity in tagalog,stephen hawking iq,galaxies mtl,galaxies mtl rda,starsailor,cosmology baumann pdf,einstein tower,cosmology articles,marsupial,2-drawer vertical file cabinet,einstein contribution,physics textbook,astronomy books,expanding file,space news reddit,universe expansion acceleration,galaxy m10,expansion anchor,2-d array,astronomy domine,galaxies lointaines,2-d blacktop,marshall islands,cosmos pizza,big bang theory finale,space time manipulation,4-dmap,what is the universe expanding into ted,2-drawer storage shelf,expansionary monetary policy,what is our universe expanding into,infinite looper,dark energy book,expanding universe evidence,expanding universe speed,what is the universe expanding into bbc,einstein refrigerator,universe expansion accelerating,expanding universe book,einstein cause of death,general relativity wald pdf,fraser cain death threats,3-drive,dark energy power bank,space race,marshall faulk,expansionary fiscal policy,3-drive・α,relativity movie,dark energy minneapolis,space news uk,http://spacenews.com,spaceballs,einstein formula,galaxy a80,galaxy note 8,mars bar,metric expansion of space rate,expanding universe balloon lab,3-dセキュア visa,cosmology axis of evil,big bang theory,physics reference table,science of the total environment,dark energy is an unexplained force that is causing,c-space 15.6 backpack,science fiction movies,space time ninjutsu,3-d天国,gravity formula,fraser cains grange hill,einstein theory,cosmology and astronomy,nasa astronauts,3-drive・ac,universe expansion nasa,space time compression example,einstein exchange,c-space newquay,universe expansion evidence,stephen hawking big bang theory,expanding universe activity,starsky,infinite stratos,big bang theory bernadette,earthquake los angeles,space (quotation subject),space time diagram,physics today,dark energy manipulation,cosmology calculator,universe wallpaper,space force,space time warp,relativity meaning,science news,einstein death,dark energy tech,science traduccion,ted ed what is the universe expanding into,dark energy and dark matter,nasa amazon fire,space movies,marshalls,universe towing,infinite loop,c-space limited,cosmos carl sagan,nasa logo,3-drive · evo,space invaders,general relativity action,universe appliance,einstein on the beach,universe expansion rate increasing,marsala wine,universe today earth,expanding universe of ashley garcia cast,cosmos tours,space news australia,what space is the universe expanding into,physics news,gravity falls,cosmology kills,what is the universe expanding into quora,universe pictures,cosmos definition,relativity the special and the general theory مترجم,earthquake,marsha edwards,space station,big bang theory last episode,spacex launch,galaxies mtl rdta - vapefly,big bang members,physics subject test,expansion valve,space news magazine,dark energy star,marshmello face,expansion diffusion example,science citation index,expansion explosion,einstein brain,galaxies visibles,infinite warfare,c-space concordia,2-door jeep wrangler,what is the universe expanding into reddit,4dx,cosmos netflix,space shuttle,galaxies revue,space camp,big bang theory cast,astronomy linux,infinite discs,fraser cain astronomy,cosmology baumann,astronomy wallpaper,cosmology pdf,universe expansion speed,infinite loop apple,general relativity robert wald pdf,expanding universe redshift,earthbound,4-delige bk conical cool glas set met koekenpan,general relativity exercises,expanding universe definition,gravity falls season 3,stephen hawking biography,space time curvature,universe dota,gravity google,marseille,expanding meaning,infinite campus pausd,stars wars,universe toyota,earthworm sally,dark energy pokemon,